hubertkoh wrote:Richard, think of it as a placebo effect.
The placebo is a sugar pill. It doesn't cure the cancer. The person believes, they feel better temporarily, then they die. That is why it is called the "placebo effect" and not the "placebo cure".
Don't get me wrong, I understand the value in some cases of offering a placebo. When I was in Chiapas Mexico I witnessed priests sacrificing chickens to cure illness. In some cases, maybe the positive beliefs even helped provide a physiological boost. If a person believes the death of a chicken will cure them, it helps get them active and this extra activity boosts the immune system. Woohoo! Go placebo! Sorry chicken, but your life was sacrificed for a good cause.
Now Chiapas is a poor community. There are no hospitals so sometimes sacrificing a chicken is the best therapy available. A placebo effect is better than no treatment at all.
Regardless, most situations are not so desperate that a person only has the option of sacrificing a chicken or praying to water in order to garner a placebo. In an online public forum, other options than the placebo effect are available. That is why I believe offering up multiple opinions is the best path. You disagree? You think only offering the placebo effect is the best path?