MichelleKingman wrote:is to be able to not be affected by what other people do, think and say... This is a really big goal for me, to be able to be strong enough to be emotionally and mentally clear regardless of what other people are doing. Once I achieve that, I feel that I will actually be in control of my own life and not just pushed around by other people. Currently if someone else is upset with me... it drags me down.. but I am working on that.
We have an offensive person at the gym who sucks people in with inflammatory remarks and then uses illogical arguments to keep the debate going, while thoroughly enjoying himself. I think he wants attention and I feel this is an illegitimate way to get it.
I first look for logical flaws in his position, then if anything remains, whether there is any truth in what he says.
If it is personal remarks, I know myself (there are textbooks about my personality type) so I can check the validity.
I try to categorize his method: ad hominem, straw man argument, bandwagon, etc..
Then I figure out ways to stop him, either gently or in a way that he will find unpleasant.
Insight can be used to heal or to hurt. Peg him in the DSM if you can and use this info to tell him about himself with unsettling accuracy.
You are also free to say, "I find your conduct offensive."
If he wants to regain control by asking questions, you can say "I don't wish to say."
If he calls you names, he is "defining" you, which is one method abusers use, according to Virginia Satir.
It's verbal judo.
Yesterday a clerk at the Home Depot was rude. After I finally got my correct change I said, "Your body language tells me that you hate this job." [process commentary] Then, "Do you hate this job?"
She looked at me with narrowed eyes and said, "No, I don't hate this job." I said, "Good. Because the next time this happens I will be talking to your supervisor."
But. . .my bad. . .I forgot to say the last words with a snarl and loud enough to attract attention.
If the situation calls for it, show your upper and lower teeth - it makes people stop and think. Rally as much hatred as you can and use your abdominal muscles to give your voice real force. Then switch back to a normal tone.
People have countermoves to these tactics and you will learn them over the years. Just when you think you've seen the last word game, another one pops up. It helps if you mentally have three or more responses at the ready.
If it's between men and women, Deborah Tannen wrote about their different styles and the resulting confusion, and I still get into situations right out of her books.