by BatFonz » Sat Nov 10, 2007 5:21 pm
I know this isn't specifically Hypnosis related but I know we discuss Derren in some depth in other threads so thought I'd post a brief summation of my thoughts on Pure Effect by Derren Brown
Firstly I solve problems for a living and as such my personality is very much skewed towards understanding all the details that make something work. So with that in mind you need to take what I say next in context that my expectations and others may be very different.
Pure Effect is a very, very engaging book at least I found it so - Derren really just explains several tricks he performed/performs in a step-by-step manner. Along the way we get some of Derren's views concerning how he approaches his tricks & what he personally is trying to achieve.
All in all I enjoyed it...but... yep there's is a 'but'
But IMHO it has been over-hyped, perhaps this is to get more money off us interested parties via eBay or other sites but to get your hands on a legal copy you are looking at £70+ least that's what it cost me. Now the money is one thing, not my main issue because as I said I’m interested in the 'how' he achieves his effects so I would of been willing to pay 100 times more than that to gain some real insight.
I think where I was disappointed was that the full title is 'Pure Effect - Direct Mind-reading & Magical Artistry'. Well I think it is a fantastic book relating to the magical artistry side but the direct mind-reading was minimal I felt. Now I didn't think there was some special trick & once I understood it I would be able to plant thoughts in others heads but I was hopeful he might give more away about his techniques for influencing people. I think where he lost me was during a part where he described 'fully believing' that you can read someone's mind and then basically guessing - if it goes wrong you can joke your way out of it. I understood this approach ala Banachek's fall-back positions for this type of thing but I have been fascinated for years after watching him on mainstream shows seeming to literally mind-read.
I suspect as with most things my own expectation hurt my enjoyment of this book rather than the content, all I would say is if you are interested in Magic over Derren's other aspects of his shows you will not be disappointed, it is a fabulous book in this respect.
I know a lot of you guys have posted that you have an interest personal / professional in Mentalism so I was wondering, I have read '13 Steps...' and 'Psychological Subtleties', other books from Amazon but... what do you recommend? am I even looking in the right places to gain a better understanding?
Thanks, Simon